The NMJI

VOLUME 17 NUMBER 5 SEPTEMBER / OCTOBER 2004

Short Reports

Tobacco water: A special form of tobacco use in the Mizoram and Manipur states of India [PDF]

D. N. SINHA, P. C. GUPTA, M. PEDNEKAR


ABSTRACT
    Background. Tuibur and hidakphu are watery tobacco products made by passing tobacco smoke through water. These have neither been described in the health literature nor are there any reports of epidemiological studies on these products. We collected information on the use of these products in Mizoram and Manipur.
    Methods. We conducted two surveys. In the first, we spoke to personnel involved in tobacco water manufacturing, marketing and sale. In the second, we carried out a house to house survey of adults on the attitude and behaviour towards the use of tobacco products in 25 randomly selected villages each in Aizawl district of Mizoram and Churchandpur district of Manipur.
    Results. About 7% of persons surveyed in Aizawl (872 of 12 185) and Churchandpur (139 of 2137) used tobacco water, which is stored and sold in bottles. It is sipped and retained in the mouth for 5–10 minutes and then spat out. Among tobacco water users, about 90% of users in Churchandpur and about 40% in Aizawl sipped tobacco water more than 5 times a day. The use of other tobacco products in both districts was also high.
    Conclusion. The use of tobacco water has been a part of the culture of some communities in Mizoram and Manipur for a long time. These communities also have a very high incidence of tobacco use. To discourage the use of such tobacco products, these communities should be educated about the harmful effects of tobacco use on a priority.

Natl Med J India 2004;17:245–7

INTRODUCTION
Tobacco is used in many forms. The most common of these is as a cigarette. However, in India, a wide range of smokeless tobacco products are also used.
1 While conducting the Global Youth Tobacco Survey2 in the states of Mizoram and Manipur in the northeastern region of India, we came across the use of a hitherto undescribed tobacco product called tuibur in Mizoram and hidakphu in Manipur—a form of tobacco water. A literature review revealed that hookah (hubble bubble) is smoked in Mizoram and Manipur as in other parts of India but we did not come across the use of tuibur or hidakphu. In this, water impregnated with the use of tuibur or hidakphu. In this, water impregnated with tobacco smoke in a water receptacle is poured out through the mouthpiece of a pipe into a tobacco water flask and preserved for personal use. Usually, in one sip, 5–10 ml of tobacco water is kept in the mouth for 5–10 minutes and then spat out. It is either sipped directly from the bottle or through cotton soaked with tobacco water. People initially use tobacco water to clean their teeth or protect themselves from insect bites, but soon start sipping it several times a day and get addicted.3,4
    Tobacco water (tuibur) has been in use since the nineteenth century. A definite record of its use is available since 1907. Men and women alike sip tobacco water. In the past, it was predominantly used by women
3,4 and was offered to guests or visitors. It was a form of greeting and it was considered rude not to offer it. It was an essential item at parties in rural areas. A family generally owned three tobacco water flasks—one carried by the husband, one by the wife and a spare one kept in the house. No adult went around without a flask. This was a common feature among the Lakhers (a tribal community in Mizoram) in the urban and rural areas. During the process of courting, a girl would offer tobacco water to the boy. If the boy refused the tobacco water, it was presumed that he had no interest in the girl.
    No epidemiological studies of this form of tobacco use have been reported in the literature. We, therefore, collected information about this product and the frequency of its use in different communities.

METHODS
Trained investigators (both men and women) collected information from different parts of Mizoram and Manipur. We obtained information about the different types and cost of tobacco water from 42 personnel involved in its manufacture, marketing and sale. We also conducted an attitude and behaviour survey among the population during September–December 2001.
    A village-wise population list was obtained from the district offices in Aizawl district in Mizoram and Churchandpur district in Manipur. These districts had 358 and 107 villages, respectively. A random sample of 25 villages from each district was selected. All adults (>15 years of age) were eligible to participate in the survey. A house to house survey was conducted using a structured interview format by trained investigators. The survey was repeated on a sample of 5% of the surveyed population. The results were analysed with SPSS.

RESULTS

Information on tobacco water production, marketing and sale
A small amount of tobacco water may be prepared at home for household use and sale. Tobacco water production is a small scale industry. Imported tobacco from Myanmar is cheaper compared to tobacco from other parts of India. A typical factory set-up may produce 500 L of tobacco water in one month. A space of 8¢x 8¢ is sufficient for one small production unit located near a source of water (such as a waterfall or fountain). One iron oven with a few pipes and containers is required and costs around Rs 3000 (about US$ 70). The average monthly income from one such unit is Rs 7000 (about US$ 155). The tuibur manufacturing units are run in bamboo thatched structures in Mizoram (Fig. 1).
Table I. Parameters used to grade tobacco water available in the market
Grade
Amount of tobacco required to be burnt (kg)
Time used to process (hours)
Amount of water used (L)
Amount of tobacco water produced (L)
Price in Rs per litre
First
21
18
20
20
38
Second
14
12
20
20
15
Third
7
6
20
20
12

    The quality of tobacco water is graded according to the concentration of tobacco smoke in the water. This is based on the quantity of tobacco used and the time taken for production—higher the concentration, better the quality (Table I). Tobacco water is sold in used glass bottles at many places such as stationery shops, daily markets or weekly markets (Fig. 2).


Survey on the use of tobacco water

Of the 25 villages selected in each district, 23 villages in Aizawl district and 24 in Churchandpur district were surveyed. Two villages in Aizawl and 1 in Churchandpur districts were uninhabited. A total of 14 322 adults responded to the survey (response rate 100%). Six houses were found to be locked (three in each district). An almost equal proportion of men and women were included in both the districts (Table II).
Table II. Tobacco water use in Aizawl and Churchandpur districts
Gender
Number surveyed
Frequency of tobacco use n (%)
 
Tobacco water
Any form
Aizawl district (Mizoram)
Men
6154
476 (7.7)
5120 (83.2)
Women
6031
396 (6.6)
4423 (73.3)
Total
12 185
872 (7.2)
9543 (78.3)
Churchandpur district (Manipur)
Men
1119
69 (6.2)
897 (80.2)
Women
1018
70 (6.9)
784 (77.0)
Total
2137
139 (6.5)
168 (78.7)

    About 7% of men and women reported the use of tobacco water, although the use of other forms of tobacco was much higher (Table II). The frequency of use of tobacco water varied from 1 to 30 times a day. Tobacco water was used >5 times a day by 36.7% of users in Aizawl district and 92.1% of users in Churchandpur (Table III)

Table III. Frequency of use of tobacco water per day
Frequency
Aizawl district (%)
Churchandpur district (%)
1–5
552 (63.3)
11 (7.9)
6–10
214 (24.6)
51 (36.7)
>11
106 (12.1)
77 (55.4)

    About 90% of the people in both districts believed that tobacco water protects against the bites of insects and paalu (a common insect in the region). They believe that it acts as an antiseptic, protects the teeth and has antisnake venom properties.

DISCUSSION
The use of tobacco water is integrated with the social and cultural rituals of communities in Mizoram and Manipur. Misconceptions about the benefits of using tobacco water are widespread.
    The overall use of tobacco in the two districts surveyed was very high (78.3% and 78.7%); among men it was 83% and 80% and among women it was 73% and 77%, respectively. It can be hypothesized that a very high prevalence of tobacco use could be attributed to the widespread cultural acceptance of the use of tobacco water in the community.
    Like other tobacco products, tobacco water is used many times a day by most users and therefore seems to be equally addictive. Tobacco smoke contains nicotine and thus tobacco water is likely to have different concentrations of nicotine. Thus, even in low concentrations one would expect tobacco to be present in tobacco water and exert its addictive influence, reinforcing the need for strong economic, legislative and educational means to eradicate this menace.
    The local governments and non-governmental organizations have taken some initiatives to educate the people regarding the harmful effects of tobacco and tobacco water. However, much more needs to be done including possibly enacting legislation to stop the use of tobacco water.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We sincerely thank Mr Lalthuama, Chairman of Banks, Aizawl and Late Kuber Singh of Manipur for their help and guidance.

REFERENCES
  1. Bhonsle RB, Murti PR, Gupta PC. Tobacco habits in India. In: Gupta PC, Hamner JE, Murti PR (eds). Control of tobacco-related cancers and other diseases. Proceedings of an international symposium, 1990. Mumbai: Oxford University Press; 1992.
  2. Sinha DN, Gupta PC, Pednekar M. Tobacco use among students in the eight north-eastern states of India. Indian J Cancer 2003;40:43–59.
  3. Parry NE, Hutton JH. The Lakhers. Aizawl, Mizoram:Firma KLM on behalf of Tribal Research Institute; 1932, reprint 1976:90–2.
  4. Thenga L, Lalmatfela VL, Fimate L. Material culture of Mizos. Aizawl:Tribal Research Institute, Department of Art and Culture, Government of Mizoram; 1964:108–12.
School of Preventive Oncology, A/27, Anandpuri, Patna, Bihar 800001, India
D. N. SINHA
Sekhsaria Institute of Public Health, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
P. C. GUPTA, M. PEDNEKAR
Correspondence to D. N. SINHA; dhirendrasinha1@hotmail.com, ds1@sancharnet.in
© The National Medical Journal of India 2004


Search
NMJI Web
 
Contact Us | Site Map | Feedback | Disclaimer